The Formal Investigation
Chapter 11 - The Formal Investigation
Detective Ostrander's formal interview with Edmund, conducted three days after he regained consciousness, produced exactly the kind of careful, lawyered denial his family had come to expect, though the accumulated weight of evidence made that denial considerably less effective than it might once have been.
"My client has no memory of any inappropriate conduct," Edmund's attorney stated, during the recorded interview. "Any interactions in that study were entirely professional in nature."
Ostrander, unmoved, laid out the security footage timestamp by timestamp, the four women's corroborating testimony, and a specific pattern that made continued denial increasingly untenable given the sheer volume of consistent, independent accounts.
"I'd recommend discussing plea options with your client," Ostrander told the attorney, once the interview concluded. "Given the strength of this evidence, I believe a trial would only prolong what's already a very clear picture for anyone reviewing this case objectively."
The formal charges, filed the following week, included four counts of sexual assault and battery, spanning the seven-year period the investigation had documented, along with additional charges related to the specific incident involving Bianca that had precipitated the entire case becoming public.
Edmund's legal team mounted an aggressive defense over the following months, challenging the security footage's admissibility, questioning the timeline of each victim's account, and attempting, repeatedly, to characterize the entire case as a family dispute that had spiraled unnecessarily out of proportion.
"They're going to try to make this look like a business rivalry, or a jealous wife's overreaction," Marisol warned the family, during one of their regular strategy meetings. "I want you all prepared for a defense that tries very hard to minimize four women's documented experiences into something considerably smaller and more dismissible."
Bianca, sitting through these meetings with a specific, hard-won resolve that had grown steadily over the preceding months, found herself increasingly willing to speak publicly about what had happened, despite the exhausting scrutiny that public visibility inevitably invited.
"I want to give a statement to the press," she told Marisol, during one particularly difficult week. "Not just to the investigators. I want people to understand exactly what happened, in my own words, rather than whatever version his defense team tries to construct instead."
Marisol considered the request carefully. "That's a significant decision, Bianca. Once you speak publicly, there's no taking it back. I want you certain this is what you actually want, not simply what feels urgent in this specific moment."
"I'm certain," Bianca said. "I spent one night in that ballroom letting everyone believe I was simply violent, unstable, dangerous, because I couldn't find the words to explain what had actually happened. I don't want to carry that silence any longer than I already have."
Claire, Priya, and Grace each made similar decisions over the following weeks, a coordinated but individually chosen series of public statements that transformed the case from a private family scandal into something considerably larger, a story that resonated, uncomfortably and powerfully, with women across the country who recognized, in these four accounts, patterns from their own carefully buried experiences.
May you like
"I've received messages from over two hundred women since my statement went public," Grace told the family, during a gathering three months into the case's public phase. "Women I've never met, describing similar experiences with men in positions of power in their own lives. I had no idea speaking out could matter this much, beyond just my own healing."
Adrian, listening to Grace's account, felt a specific, complicated pride in the women who had chosen, one after another, to transform an isolated, terrible experience into something that was slowly, visibly helping considerably more people than just themselves.
