newscapedaily

The Trial

Chapter 7: The Trial

Winslow and Pryce went to trial in February.

The case was federal — trafficking charges, conspiracy, fraud, the full architecture of a criminal enterprise dismantled and laid out in a courtroom for a jury of twelve people who had never imagined that such things could be done to children by people who looked like lawyers and social workers.

Torres was the lead case agent. She presented the evidence with the same methodical precision she'd brought to every stage of the investigation — the financial records, the communications, the testimony of Warren (who had flipped in exchange for a reduced sentence and was now the prosecution's primary cooperating witness), Diane's account, Howell's records.

Diane testified on the third day.

She'd been granted immunity in exchange for full cooperation — Torres's recommendation had carried weight with the prosecutor's office, and the deal had been structured to reflect the reality that Diane had been coerced into participation and had engineered the rescue that broke the case open.

She took the stand in a dark dress that someone — maybe Torres, maybe the victim's advocate — had helped her choose. She looked different from the woman in the sundress at the rally. Not just the clothes — the posture, the voice, the eyes. The performance was gone. What was left was a woman telling the truth about the worst experience of her life to a room full of strangers.

She told them about Paul. About the two-thousand-dollar offer. About the empty house in Waterbury and the child standing in it with no furniture and no one. She told them about the three months of moving Emma, the phone calls, the threats. She told them about the note.

"I wrote five words," she said. "Five words on a piece of paper, and I put it in a seven-year-old's pocket, and I told her to find the biggest, scariest man she could see." She looked at the jury. "That was my entire plan. That was everything I had."

The defense attorney — Pryce's lawyer, a man named Thornton who was being paid an amount that suggested Pryce's clients had deep pockets — tried to discredit Diane on cross-examination. He suggested she'd been a willing participant who had invented the coercion narrative to avoid prosecution. He suggested the note was a fabrication. He suggested she'd been planning to sell Emma herself and had used the rally as a cover story.

Diane sat through it. She answered each question the way Torres had coached her — directly, without elaboration, with the steady voice of a person who has nothing to hide and is tired of people suggesting otherwise.

"Ms. Hewitt," Thornton said. "If you were truly a victim, why didn't you simply call 911?"

"Because Paul told me he had people in the system. Because I had a seven-year-old child in my care who had already been failed by every system she'd been in. Because the last time a system was supposed to protect her, she ended up in an empty house with no furniture." Diane looked at Thornton steadily. "I didn't trust the system. I trusted a parking lot full of bikers."

Bull, sitting in the gallery, heard a juror in the second row make a sound that might have been a laugh or might have been something closer to crying.

The jury deliberated for four hours. Guilty on all counts — trafficking, conspiracy, fraud, endangering the welfare of minors. Winslow received eighteen years. Pryce received twenty-two. Howell, who had been tried separately in Pennsylvania, received fifteen.

Diane walked out of the courthouse into the February cold and stood on the steps and looked at the sky like she was seeing it for the first time, which, in a way, she was.

Bull was waiting at the bottom of the steps. Not because he'd planned to — because Emma had asked him to be there. Emma, who was back in Roanoke with Mrs. Kim, who was making pancakes on Saturdays and going to school and sleeping in a bedroom with her name on the door, had called Bull two nights before the verdict and said, "Make sure Diane's not alone when it's over."

"She's not alone," Bull had told Emma.

"Promise."

"I promise."

So he was there. Standing at the bottom of the courthouse steps, in his leather vest in the February wind, waiting for a woman he'd once accused of abducting a child to come out of a building where she'd just helped put the real abductors away.

Diane saw him. She came down the steps slowly, her coat pulled tight.

"Emma sent me," he said.

"Of course she did." Diane almost smiled. "She's the most organized person I've ever met. Seven years old and she runs the world."

"She told me to make sure you weren't alone."

"I'm not alone." Diane looked at him. "I haven't been alone since the rally. Torres calls every week. The victim's advocate has been — I have people now. For the first time in a long time."

"Good."

"Bull." She paused. "I heard about your daughter. About Chloe."

He nodded.

"I hope you find her."

"They found her," he said. "Torres's team. She's been in Pennsylvania the whole time. She's eighteen."

Diane pressed her hand over her mouth. The gesture of a person receiving good news that is too big to process standing on a courthouse step in the cold.

"Have you seen her?"

"Saturday," he said. "I'm driving to Scranton on Saturday."

"Are you scared?"

Bull looked at the courthouse. At the building where justice had just been done, imperfectly and slowly and twelve years too late for some of the children in those fifty-three files.

May you like

"Terrified," he said.

"Good." Diane pulled her coat tighter. "Terrified means it matters."

Other posts