The Medicine Cabinet
PART 3: "The Medicine Cabinet"
Detective Rosa Méndez arrived at 2:15 PM.
She came alone. Unmarked car. No uniform — plain clothes, dark jacket, the understated appearance of a woman who has learned that showing up to a wealthy household in a police car tends to make evidence disappear faster than it can be collected.
Méndez was forty-four years old. Dominican. She'd been in the Major Crimes unit for twelve years, the last five in the child abuse division, which was the kind of job that either hardens you or breaks you and that had done both to her in roughly equal measure.
She photographed the tacks. Bagged them. Documented the crib, the mattress pad, the positioning. She examined Oliver — gently, with gloved hands — and photographed the marks on his back with a scale ruler beside them for size reference.
"How old is the baby?"
"Ten months," Sofia said.
"And you've been here three weeks?"
"Yes."
"Has the baby cried like this before?"
"Every night. Catherine says he's colicky. She takes a sleeping pill and closes her door."
Méndez wrote that down.
"Where is Mrs. Whitfield now?"
"Boston. Back at four."
"And the husband?"
"James Whitfield. He travels for work. I've seen him twice in three weeks."
Méndez looked at the nursery. At the gray-blue walls and the silver mobile and the crib that looked like it belonged in a catalog and that had twenty-six thumbtacks hidden under the mattress.
"I need to see the rest of the house."
---
They started in the master bedroom on the third floor.
Sofia had only been in this room twice — both times to change the sheets. Catherine's space was off-limits the way the nursery was off-limits. Rules. Architecture.
The bedroom was enormous. A king bed with white linen. Windows overlooking the harbor. A walk-in closet the size of Sofia's entire apartment in Lawrence.
Méndez went to the bathroom.
The medicine cabinet was behind the mirror above the double vanity. Chrome frame, glass shelves, the kind of cabinet that rich people install because it looks clean and modern and hides things so well that you forget they're there.
Méndez opened it.
Twelve bottles.
Not unusual for a medicine cabinet. What was unusual was the combination. Méndez had seen enough medicine cabinets in enough homes to recognize patterns, and the pattern in Catherine Whitfield's cabinet was one she'd seen before.
Ambien — for sleep.
Xanax — for anxiety.
Zoloft — for depression.
And a fourth bottle that Méndez picked up and held close to her face.
Haloperidol.
An antipsychotic.
Prescribed by a Dr. Richard Keane. Dated two months ago. The bottle was almost empty.
"This is a serious medication," Méndez said to Dr. Park, who was standing in the bathroom doorway. "Haloperidol is used for severe psychiatric conditions. Psychosis. Mania. Severe agitation."
Dr. Park took the bottle. Read the label.
"It's also used, in some cases, for severe postpartum psychosis."
They looked at each other.
"If Catherine Whitfield is experiencing postpartum psychosis," Dr. Park said carefully, "she may not be fully aware of what she's doing. PPP can cause hallucinations, delusions, paranoid thinking, and in severe cases, a complete disconnect between a mother and her child."
"You're saying she might have placed the tacks and not remember it?"
"I'm saying it's possible. PPP is one of the most dangerous and least understood postpartum conditions. Women who experience it can behave in ways that are completely inconsistent with their normal personality."
Méndez put the bottle back.
"Or someone is medicating her to make her seem unstable while someone else hurts the baby."
The bathroom went quiet.
"That's also possible," Dr. Park said.
---
May you like
Keep reading Part 4 — because when Catherine comes home at four o'clock and finds a detective in her house, she doesn't deny anything. She doesn't call a lawyer. She sits on the nursery floor and says five words that change the entire investigation: "I've been trying to stop it."
============================================================
